Toro Y Moi tops our charts with his sun-drenched What For?
| Rank | Artist | Recording | Label | User Supplied Version |
| 1 | TORO Y MOI | What For? | Carpark | |
| 2 | SUFJAN STEVENS | Carrie And Lowell | Asthmatic Kitty | |
| 3 | COURTNEY BARNETT | Sometimes I Sit And Think, And Sometimes I Just Sit | Mom And Pop | |
| 4 | SAN CISCO | Gracetown | Island City | |
| 5 | CALEXICO | Edge Of The Sun | Anti | |
| 6 | TICA DOUGLAS | Joey | Self-Released | |
| 7 | WAXAHATCHEE | Ivy Tripp | Merge | |
| 8 | CHASTITY BELT | Time To Go Home | Hardly Art | |
| 9 | LOWER DENS | Escape From Evil | Ribbon | |
| 10 | GHASTLY MENACE | Songs Of Ghastly Menace | Record Machine | |
| 11 | MONOPHONICS | Sound Of Sinning | Transistor | |
| 12 | KING KHAN AND BBQ SHOW | Bad News Boys | In The Red | |
| 13 | PAPERWHITE | Magic | Self-Released | |
| 14 | TEMPLE INVISIBLE * | Enter EP * | * | waiting for CMJ verification |
| 15 | WHAT TYRANTS | No Luck | Forged Artifacts | |
| 16 | ALEX G | Trick | Lucky Number | |
| 17 | PURITY RING | Another Eternity | 4AD | |
| 18 | PRINZE GEORGE | Prinze George | Sounds Expensive | |
| 19 | SUNFLOWER BEAN | Show Me Your Seven Secrets [EP] | Self-Released | |
| 20 | YUMI ZOUMA | EP I And EP II | Cascine | |
| 21 | WAND | Golem | In The Red | |
| 22 | SPEEDY ORTIZ | Foil Deer | Carpark | |
| 23 | HOCKEY DAD | Dreamin’ | Farmer And The Owl | |
| 24 | MOUNTAIN GOATS | Beat The Champ | Merge | |
| 25 | SHLOHMO | Dark Red | WeDidIt-True Panther Sounds | |
| 26 | TIMBRE | Sun And Moon | Self-Released | |
| 27 | AVID DANCER | 1st Bath | Grand Jury | |
| 28 | PEACH KELLI POP | III | Burger | |
| 29 | KATHRYN CALDER | Kathryn Calder | File Under: Music | |
| 30 | MODEST MOUSE | Strangers To Ourselves | Epic |
Adds:
| Rank | Artist | Recording | Label | User Supplied Version |
| 1 | DJANGO DJANGO | Born Under Saturn | Ribbon | |
| 2 | SURFER BLOOD | 1000 Palms | Joyful Noise | |
| 3 | BLUR | The Magic Whip | Warner Brothers | |
| 4 | MY MORNING JACKET | The Waterfall | Capitol | |
| 5 | WARM SODA | Symbolic Dream | Castle Face |